C Grade Question
A)How does Shakespeare present Juliet’s father in Act 3 scene 5?
Shakespeare presents Juliet’s father in a negative light; he is seen as controlling and aggressive in Act 3 Scene 5.
In the 1500s a family’s reputation and status was important and Capulet shows this attitude by arranging the marriage between his daughter Juliet and Paris. He sees this as a way of enhancing his family’s status in Verona by using his daughter like a pawn to marry the rich and powerful Paris. Shakespeare says that Capulet asks his wife “Have you delivered to her our decree.” Shakespeare uses the word ‘decree’ here to show the dictatorial and ruling nature of Capulet. Juliet is his property to make decisions about as he sees fit. This clearly engages the audience to dislike Capulet and feel sympathy for Juliet as she is the victim of her father’s controlling and scheming nature.
However, when Juliet refuses to marry Paris he quickly turns to anger and shows his aggressive side. Shakespeare makes Capulet use a wide range of exclamation marks and questions marks that he fires at Juliet which further demonstrates his aggressive and angry nature, such as “How now, How now, chop-logic! What is this?” Shakespeare also gets Capulet to fire a nasty range of insults at Juliet to show his displeasure at her refusal, such as “tallow-face, minion, unworthy, carrion, baggage.” Shakespeare uses these terms to show how little Capulet thinks of his daughter and clearly shows he believes that Capulet is in the wrong and that the audience should feel sympathy for Juliet and how she is unfairly treated by her own father.
B) Do you think the adults in the play are good role models to the younger generation? Refer closely to different parts of the play in your answer.
Shakespeare tends to present the adults in the play as poor role models. The fathers of the families, Capulet and Montague have allowed their pettiness and ‘ancient grudge’ poison the futures of their children through the deaths of Tybalt, Mercutio, Paris and Romeo and Juliet. They do not show any contrition for their feud until after the death of these 5 individuals. However, Capulet does tell Tybalt to ‘endure’ the presence of Romeo at the party in Act 1 Scene 5 when the young Capulet wants to cause a scene, which could suggest he knows when to show restraint in certain situations.
The Friar can be seen as good adult role model in the play. When Romeo falls in love with he sees a possible repairing of the relationship between the two families and to “turn your households’ rancour to pure love”. Even though he agrees to a secret marriage his overall aim is to bring about peace and restoration which shows he has a strong moral core in everything he does. Furthermore, he instructs Romeo and Juliet at the wedding service to “love moderately” which suggest Shakespeare’s attitudes that young lovers should work towards a more mature relationship and look beyond the first flush of love towards a relationship of stability. Friar Lawrence also criticises Romeo after he has killed Tybalt when he says “hold thy desperate hand, art thou a man?” which suggests that Romeo should have been more mature and turned away rather than kill Tybalt, showing that the Friar is keen to show Romeo how to act maturely. Shakespeare raises the question of adults taking responsibility for their own actions and shows the Friar do this towards the end of the play when he is desperately trying to contact Romeo. He says “If aught in this, miscarried by my fault: let my old life be sacrificed.” Which demonstrates his willingness to suffer the consequences of losing his own life if his plan causes the death of others. This clearly shows the audience a high level of maturity and responsibility that Romeo doesn’t display at the end of the play.
A Grade
How does Shakespeare present the relationship between Juliet and her parents?
Shakespeare presents the relationship between Juliet and her parents in many different ways. Firstly, the relationship between her father and herself displays many similarities through their headstrong personalities. The relationship with her mother is very different, Lady Capulet is quite subservient, but also vain and selfish like a husband, whereas Juliet is more principled and moral and will challenge them both. Shakespeare presents the relationships as complex and dynamic that raises issues of gender inequality that reflects the context of when the play was written.
The personalities of Lord Capulet and Juliet share many similarities. Capulet shows a sensitive and principled side to his character when he first talks to Paris of the proposed marriage to Juliet does seem to show some care for his daughter and her viewpoints about the marriage when he says, “my will to her consent is but a part” which suggests that he will accept whoever she chooses to marry rather than marry who he decides. However, this sensitive attitude soon changes in Act 3 Scene 5 when Juliet refuses to marry Paris; Capulet’s domineering personality comes to the fore. He uses lots of aggressive language and punctuation to display his anger. For example, “I will drag you the honour hurdle thither!” which suggests a violent and aggressive action to ensure that she will marry Paris. He also uses very negative language such as “green sickness, carrion, baggage,” which shows that he sees Juliet is almost like a lifeless corpse but also a piece of meat that can be bought or sold which links very clearly to his intention to make her marry Paris like a business transaction.
Juliet shows similar characteristics to her father in her strong will and her unwillingness not to yield anyone else’s will but her own. In Act 3 Scene 5, when Capulet tells her of the proposed marriage to Paris, he accuses her of not being proud of what he’s done for her. She replies that she is “not proud” but “thankful” which suggests that she is respectful of her father for trying to arrange the marriage but she clearly says “proud can I never be of what I hate” which strongly displays a negative attitude towards the match with Paris. This again shows her strong will that she will not do as her father says, but does it in a respectful way. When he rages against her in his aggressive way she uses the pleading term “beseech” to get him to listen to her. Again this shows her respectful attitude but also her willingness to stand firm in her beliefs. Shakespeare presents the similarities between the two characters that Capulet domineering attitude will which leads Juliet to make the very wilful decision to commit suicide as it was the only way out of her predicament. Shakespeare could be suggesting that because of the patriarchal domination of Capulet’s towards his daughter he transfers those qualities to Juliet, but when she shows those qualities he reacts angrily. Also, Shakespeare could be suggesting that the aggressive patriarchal male dominated society of the late 1500s leads to the alienation of young females through Juliet and eventually with tragic consequences of her death.
The relationship between mother and daughter is very different. The mother does show a similar obsession with status and social standing like her husband, but Lady Capulet does not show a strong will. In Act 1 Scene 3, she talks to Juliet that “you shall share all that he possess” when she refers to Juliet possibly marrying Paris. This shows her materialistic and selfish attitude towards ownership and that the marriage is all about money and social standing. Conversely, when Juliet pleads with her mother to help her after Capulet’s rage in Act 3 Scene 5, Lady Capulet just says “I have done with thee” which shows that she is abandoning her motherly duties to protect her daughter from the domination of her father which leaves Juliet no option but to seek a way out which eventually reached her suicide. Shakespeare could be implying here that women’s lack of power made it difficult for mothers to protect their daughters from the authoritarian actions of the father. He could be suggesting some sympathy for lady Capulet for the audience.
Finally, when we examine the effect of Juliet’s death on both the parents we see two very distinct and different responses. After her death Capulet realises his folly in the feud with the Montague’s. When he takes Montague’s hand he says that this is his “daughter’s jointure” where he believes that his daughter’s death has joined him together in peace with his mortal enemy. This shows that he has a realisation of what the grudge has done to his own daughter and to himself and seeks to make amends. He agrees to put up a statue of Romeo when he says “as rich shall Romeo’s by his lady lie poor sacrifices of our enmity” as he realises that the “enmity” of the feud has led to the sacrifice of his own daughter and also Montague son. This shows that he takes responsibility for the death of his own daughter and also the death of Montague’s son, as Montague does the other way round. However, Lady Capulet has a less flattering response. When she sees Juliet lying dead she can only say her death is “as a bell warms my old age to a sepulchre” which shows that Juliet reminds of her own impending death which could suggest that she is still self-centred and only focused on her own future rather than the loss of her daughter. Shakespeare could be accused of a rather negative viewpoint of women here as he presents her as shallow and self-centred, whereas Capulet is the character who seems contrite and able to be redeemable.
Overall, Shakespeare presents Juliet as similar to her father. They are both headstrong and possibly impulsive as his anger in Act 3 Scene 5 is very similar to her impulsive decision to commit suicide at the end of the play. Nonetheless, Juliet does teach him to forgive and make up with Montague. On the other hand, her mother is shown as weak, vain and self-centred and can only think of her own death when she sees her daughter’s dead body. Shakespeare presents Lady Capulet as a static character who does not change through the course of the tragedy. Whereas, Capulet, the, male is shown as a dynamic character who changes through the death of his daughter. So Shakespeare could be suggesting that men have the possibility of changing and reconciliation and self-awareness but yet women do not through the character of Lady Capulet. Yet, he does show Juliet as a strong willed female character who is young and impulsive but yet morally principled. Nevertheless, her recklessness in committing suicide could suggest an immaturity and a negative view of women. Although Capulet is shown as domineering character he does change after the tragic events, whereas both Lady Capulet and Juliet either don’t change or are destroyed by events which may suggest that their characters are weaker than men. This could show a rather misogynistic viewpoint from Shakespeare as he is a man in a world where women were not seen as strong characters. This is an interesting point as at the time Elizabeth I was ruling the country and is considered as a strong female figure, but yet Shakespeare could be inferring that women are weak in the play. Shakespeare does explore the complex dynamics between father and daughter and mother and daughter in a time when men dominated the lives of women and many fathers did decide who the children would marry. Shakespeare could be protesting against this social situation showing how the domination of parents could lead to the destruction of their children, not necessarily physically but emotionally. Shakespeare does show some hope and positivity through the healing of the feud between the families through the death of both the children. This could suggest that children can still redeem their parents no matter how bad or evil they may be, implying that parents are too blinded to see their faults only their children can see.